Tea Party Hypocrisy

April 25th, 2010 at 10:39 am | 66 Comments |

| Print

As Republicans and conservatives have scrambled to rally the support of the Tea Party movement, clinic many have failed to take notice of some of the important inconsistencies implicit in the Tea Party message.  A recent New York Times/CBS poll reveals some interesting information about the movement and its fundamental “principles.”

According to this poll, salve 91% of Tea Partiers want a smaller government with fewer services.  Despite this hostility to big government, medicine 62% of Tea Partiers believe that Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid are worth the cost (apparently no one bothered to tell them that Social Security and Medicare are evil Godless socialist programs).  This would suggest that in order to achieve fiscal sanity the Tea Party believes that spending cuts are to be implemented elsewhere within the vast expenditures of the federal apparatus.  However when one examines their beliefs on paying down the debt, the result is somewhat troubling.  When asked whether they preferred deficit reduction or tax cuts, 49% of Tea Partiers said they would favor tax reduction while 42% would prefer deficit reduction.

So, tax cuts are preferred to debt reduction, and social security and Medicare are well worth the cost.  This sounds less like a movement of mature fiscal hawks and more like one of whiny adolescents (who actually happen to be middle-aged) who want their current taxes lower and their future benefits higher.  They are only concerned with fighting government spending that benefits other people and are desperately seeking to save their own precious benefits.  They think the costs are well worth it and they have no intention of shouldering the burden themselves.  These costs will be incurred by future generations whose taxes will be higher and whose benefits will be lower or nonexistent.

I’m reminded of the Billy Joel song “We Didn’t Start the Fire.”  It seems that to the Tea Party, the national debt has just “been burning since the world’s been turning” and there is nothing that can really be done about it… in their generation.  If Republicans and conservatives are serious about conserving and reforming entitlement programs (as they should be) they need to find ways to overcome this cultural mindset which believes rights and benefits come free of any obligations and responsibilities.  They must come to realize that these obligations extend to their fellow citizens as well as future generations.  Maybe in between talk of death panels and the rising specter of Marxism, the adults can return to this national conversation and take the lead.

Recent Posts by Oliver R. Garland

66 Comments so far ↓

  • balconesfault


    What I know is a really stupid, arrogant statment when I see one.

    And it’s fun to make fun of such idiocies.

  • nhthinker

    I’ll leave to ktward to tell you what you got wrong: that is, if ktward wants to.

  • balconesfault

    LOL – you really think that ktward is going to jump into the fray to defend this particular piece of arrogant bluster from you?

    I think in the end, you come to wrong conclusions but at least you are trying to think about it, instead of the knee-jerk feel about it that we get from the liberal crowd or the progressive crowd.

    I’ll bet we’ll be waiting for quite awhile, indeed!

  • nhthinker


    You are only continuing to wrap yourself around the axle. Maybe your mother could explain it to you.

  • ktward

    nhthinker // Apr 27, 2010 at 8:24 am:
    That you were once a Republican does a lot to explain why you you try to think through a rational argument.
    For obvious reasons, I’m not flattered. But I appreciate the attempt.

    My only aim was to offer a human face to an easily dissed group of frustrated fellow Americans. But really, TeaP operates more like a Howard Beale support group than a political movement.

    I will make this clear: I’ve no patience for the bigoted ilk attached to the Right, and feel no sympathy for the derision they often receive. Karma’s a bitch.

  • ktward


    With the occasional exception, I fail at fray. I gladly defer my fray time to you. But hey, good news, I’m bilingual.

  • balconesfault

    I shall depart from this squabble, with the acknowledgment that these day’s it’s a sign of rationality to be a former Republican.

  • nhthinker

    “Squabble” would assume you had a rational leg to stand on.

    You described ktward as a “he” – I think she would have mixed emotions that you would assume her to be such-

    I guess you couldn’t help your ignorance by actually paying attention to her postings.

    But I don’t expect you to realize nor apologize for such an assumption of gender.

    Should I?

  • ktward

    nhthinker // Apr 28, 2010 at 12:56 pm
    You described ktward as a “he” – I think she would have mixed emotions that you would assume her to be such-
    I’ve no mixed emotions. On this thread, gender is irrelevant: I’ve no idea why you are using mine as a point of contention.

  • balconesfault

    Such silliness! I am quite sure that kt does not take offense at being included in “mankind” either!

    But for the record, I appreciate your gracious response kt – you are a gentleman lady and a scholar.

  • nhthinker


    “What I know is a really stupid, arrogant statment when I see one.”

    You were proven wrong after calling my statement stupid and arrogant- and you keep chuggin along without ackowledging any error.

    Typical liberal.

  • Symbolism and Humanity; What Happens When “Reality” and “Myth” Collide? » heur-e-ka

    [...] birth of the “Tea Party” only after the very embodiment of their stated platform’s arch-nemesis, big government [...]

  • pyrofighter

    Someone didn’t tell you that Social Security, and Medicare programs are funded by the workers. I’m sure the Tea Party people in the poll don’t want to see these programs cut because they’ve paid into them their entire lives!

  • Christine O'Donnell: Where in the Constitution is the Separation of Church and State

    [...] of Tea Partiers believe that Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid are worth the cost… … http://www.frumforum.com/tea-party-hypocrisy Damn these electric sex pants! 26+31+34+42+44+46+64+67+82+06 = 10 Bring back the death penalty [...]

  • Obama finds his cup of tea | PARTISANS

    [...] Moral Message Versus the Policy Message What Does Obama Really Believe? Off/Trac Holding Center? Tea Party Hypocrisy Blast from the Past Obama’s Doomed Theory of Politics Blast from the Past Losing the Future [...]