stay connected

FrumForum Facebook FrumForum YouTube Update Twitter FrumForum Flickr

Sderot, Israel Is Iraq Without The Body Armor

January 27th, 2009 at 9:48 pm Gabe Ledeen | 7 Comments |

| Print

I am no stranger to the danger of rocket and mortar fire.  As a Marine officer serving in Iraq in 2006, a 122mm rocket landed roughly 50 feet from where my Staff Sergeant and I were walking through our motor pool.  Thankfully it was a dud and didn’t explode, but the experience of hearing the incoming rocket and knowing that it was too late to take meaningful cover was truly and uniquely horrible.  Of course, we were Marines fighting in a war and were fully aware of the threats we faced.  We had body armor, armored vehicles, fortified buildings to live in, and aircraft and artillery to return fire when we were attacked.  We were in a war, we were prepared for the danger, and we knew that eventually we would go home.  For Israelis living in Sderot, Ashdod, Ashqelon, and nearby towns, it is much different.  They live in normal homes, drive normal cars, and wear normal clothes.  They eat at restaurants, watch movies, and go to school and work.  They don’t carry weapons, and they aren’t at war.  Yet they have endured over 6,500 rockets and mortars over the last three years, with 80 landing per day on the worst days.  Roughly figured, every four hours these civilians have 15 seconds to find shelter from an incoming explosive.  That is substantially more indirect fire than anything I, or anyone else that I know, ever experienced during tours in Iraq. 

As I walk the streets of Sderot I am struck by the absurdity of this situation.  These are civilians living normal lives in a normal town in a democratic country.  Yet their bus stops were converted into blast-proof shelters, and every other block has a “Lifeshield” bunker.  Camp Fallujah is the only place I’ve ever been with such “force protection” measures in place.  How absurd that Sderot is in that kind of company.  Sderot has no rocket launching pads or artillery equipment.  There are no helicopters or jets based there.  Not only is there no offensive military presence, but there is no mechanism to return fire either.  If you told Marines that they would be living in a place that received regular mortar and rocket fire, had no counter-fire capability, and would never be allowed to return fire, they would tell you that you’re completely insane…among other things. 

I am told by Sderot’s residents that there are typically two times per day that are most dangerous: when the children go to school in the morning and when the children return from school in the afternoon.  The pre-school children learn to sing songs about the proper response to the “Code Red” siren warning of an incoming rocket.  Imagine that, a child returning from school proud of the new song she learned, unaware that she lives in the only place where such songs are taught.  In Haditha and Fallujah the youngest kids that I had to worry about were 18 years old, and that was a heavy enough burden to bear. 

With only 2.5 miles between Sderot and the Gaza border, every resident remains keenly aware of the 15 second rule.  Every action is taken with the nearest bunker in mind, and every trip to school is rushed to minimize the time spent outside.  Baths and showers, bathroom breaks, wake-up times, naps, and exercise are all planned around the likely times of rocket attacks, but the residents are all too aware that there is no way to be sure.  If one is observant, the signs are everywhere.  Savage holes scar the walls of buildings, and larger holes in sidewalks and streets remind passersby of the ever-present danger.  I pass a home destroyed by a recent Qassam rocket attack, and recall the 70 year old grandmother who lived there.  She survived because she decided that morning to sleep in a bit longer; otherwise she would have been in the now non-existent kitchen or bathroom when the rocket crashed through her roof. 

Such strikes are not accidental.  These rockets are deliberately fired at civilian areas like Sderot with the intention of killing the residents as they go about their daily lives.  Every one of the 9,400 rockets fired into Israel since 2003 is a war crime.  The people of Sderot continue to wait for these charges to be made against the Hamas terrorists controlling Gaza.  They believed that the withdrawal of all Israelis from Gaza in 2005 would improve the situation, and despaired when Hamas drastically increased the number of attacks.  They live on with the hope that soon the rockets will stop.  They dream of a day when their lives will more closely resemble those of citizens of other democratic nations, and less the experiences of those of us who must endure the risks of combat.  They ask us why this dream is not possible, and we pretend not to hear.

Recent Posts by Gabe Ledeen



7 Comments so far ↓

  • senorlechero

    Thank you Gabe Ledeen, for posting the truth about the Palestinian war criminal terrorists Hamas. Israel should have finished them off in this last war, but due to the worldwide MSM distortions of the truth, as well as outright lies from the UN and certain “peace” groups, they bowed to worldwide pressure and stopped the fighting before all the rockets were destroyed and every Hamas terrorist killed. Keep posting here Gabe, this site needs as many factual posts as it can get.

  • lucas

    Good post. I look forward to your report on what it is like for the civilians in Gaza. I have heard that it is worse in Gaza in terms of numbers of civilians and children killed then the number of Georgians killed by Russia during the South Ossettia conflict. You wouldn’t know that from the MSM. Is that true?

  • senorlechero

    lucas…If “you wouldn’t know that from the MSM”, where did you hear it? The worst reports are that “half” the 1200 Palestinians killed in the assault were civilians. Even if that were true that’s an amazingly low number considering the Hamas terrorists use women and children for shields, fire rockets and mortars from hospitals and schools, set up their bases in hospitals, hide weapons in houses….and generally try to make sure that if they die, lots of “innocent” people die with them.

  • lucas

    I was referring to the US MSM (that is where i live). Would you consider BBC part of the MSM? I guess there is room for debate on that. This link suggests slightly more then 1200 are dead. They say the numbers are questionable, but you apparently want to go with the worst.

    http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/7855070.stm

    How do those numbers compare to Georgia/South Ossetia/Russia 2008 conflict?

  • senorlechero

    Lucas…I read reports every day (on the internet, for that is where I read news) during Israel’s assault that gave numbers of persons killed in Gaza. The only reason I responded to your comment was to say that the MSM reported daily on the number of “civilians and children” killed. I don’t understand the reference to Russian and Ossettia, or why you are comparing the two.

  • sinz54

    Lucas: When a regime launches an aggressive war against its neighbor (as the Hamas regime did against Israel), it invites retaliation which will invariably hurt the innocent people it leads. If Hitler had not launched an aggressive war, no German civilians would have died at Dresden. If the Japanese militarists had not bombed Pearl Harbor, no Japanese civilians would have died at Hiroshima or Nagasaki. At any point in time, Hitler, or the Japanese militarists, or HAMAS, could have chosen to end their aggression and save all peoples (including their own) any more tragedy. They chose not to. And innocent people–on BOTH sides–end up paying the price. But let’s be clear. America would NEVER have dropped an atomic bomb on Hiroshima, if Japan hadn’t launched aggressive war against its neighbors and America. And Israel would NEVER have waged war in Gaza if their civilians weren’t being constantly attacked by HAMAS rocket fire. The ultimate responsibility was not America’s then. And the ultimate responsibility is not Israel’s now.

  • lucas

    sinz54 and senorlechero,
    why are your posts directed at me? i didn’t make any arguments about whether it was justified or not. Regardless of the similarity of this occurrence with others in history, I think it would be great to see the author of this post give a civilian perspective of both sides. I am not condemning nor defending anyone. I think it is a sad situation for all the civilians involved and would love to continue to see more empathetic posts like the one’s above. I compared it to Georgia because that was also a sad situation for the civilians and I am curious how the two situation compare in scope.

Leave a Comment

You must log in to post a comment.