I never thought that my last military reserve duty (“Meluim” in Hebrew) would leave me nostalgic. Going to Meluim means dropping your family and work for up to one month every year and going back to your army unit. Typical tasks include doing guard duty in the middle of the night, shooting, helping in the kitchen, patrolling the border, and cleaning the restrooms. Then of course, there is this maddening “hurry-up and wait” pattern: You’re rushed out of bed at 5am only to be told a few minutes later that something went wrong with the schedule and that new instructions will come — maybe, sometime during the day, nobody knows. Having just turned 39 and being in a combat unit, I no longer have to deal with this. ”Good for you” you may say. Actually, what a loss.
The IDF’s reserve duty system is a logistical nightmare for the army and a highly disruptive occurrence for people with a life. And yet, it is one of the best things Israel has ever invented.
Meluim are socially and psychologically healthy. A commandant can be a 25 year-old student giving orders to a 39 year-old professor (who could incidentally be his teacher). A taxi driver can wake up the CEO of a multi-million dollar company at 3 in the morning to switch him on guard duty. A company employee can end up telling his boss to go do the dishes or clean the bathroom. I’ve seen it happen many times, and it’s always done in a good and comrade-like spirit. Meluim brings together people from all types of backgrounds and social levels. Whether you’re Ethiopian, Russian, French, or third-generation Israeli, and whether you’re a big shot or a struggling Joe Shmoe, you sleep in the same leaking tent, eat the same challenging food, and do the same unrewarding tasks. People call each other “brother,” something they rarely do in everyday life. Even army grades are mostly irrelevant: The IDF is the embodiment of Israeli informality and simplicity — as well as improvisation, constant criticism, and chutzpah.
Not only does Meluim erase social status for a few days or weeks. It is also an extremely efficient networking system. It works like an alumni club, really. Every year, the same old army buddies gather for a couple of weeks (not that they have a choice). This “reunion” brings together lawyers, engineers, salespeople, accountants, etc. who have plenty of time to talk, whether it’s in their tent, at the dinner table, or while patrolling the border in a jeep. Many business deals and ventures emerge from Meluim.
With all their complaints about the food, the cold showers and the perennial disorganization, most people actually love Meluim. They get a free vacation, drive those American WWII jeeps on sand dunes, and don’t have to deal with annoying clients or abusing bosses (if they shut their BlackBerry, that is). If war were to erupt, this summer camp atmosphere would immediately be replaced by seriousness, combativeness, and sacrifice. The IDF has not only kept Israel safe and victorious since Independence; it has also made, and continues to make, an irreplaceable contribution to the cohesion of Israeli society.
For an immigrant like me, the army is the best way (maybe the only way) to become Israeli. I might never have understood my adoptive country and fellow citizens without my military service. I’m forever grateful to the IDF not only for keeping my home safe, but also for making me feel at home in the first place. Despite the aggravation of those middle-of-the-night and pointless guarding duties, of those freezing nights in the Golan or boiling days in the desert, I will miss Meluim. Who knows: I might even be insane enough to volunteer for more.


































Sean Linnane // Feb 27, 2010 at 6:49 am
My experience was similar to yours – over some of the same terrain, in fact; I served two tours in the Multinational Force & Observers, Sinai. As it is for so many others, for me service the US military was a pathway to citizenship in my new country. Serving in the US Army helped me gain a common bond with many other Americans, both in and out of the service. Also like you, the contacts & skill sets I developed in the military have led directly to business opportunities outside of the military.
In America, of course, we have a different dynamic; service in the military is not mandatory. But for those who have served, for the rest of their lives, no matter where they are, they will have something in common with somebody else in the room, even if that person is a total stranger.
sinz54 // Feb 27, 2010 at 9:44 am
Israel, unlike the U.S., has an official religion (Judaism).
I’m curious if that influences military life in the Israeli military there. Are soldiers required to attend talks on Judaism or Jewish philosophy? While prayer can’t be required, is there enormous peer pressure to pray regularly?
My uncle used to tell us that in World War II, the soldiers were required to sit through propaganda films (presumably like Capra’s “Why We Fight”). I’m curious if a similar thing exists in the modern Israeli military.
Sean Linnane // Feb 27, 2010 at 12:20 pm
Judaism has not been proclaimed the official religion of Israel:
http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/Society_&_Culture/freedom.html
The religions officially recognized under Israeli law are: Jewish, Christian, Muslim, Druze and Baha’i. Within the Christian religion the following denominations are recognized: Greek Orthodox, Greek Catholic, Latin (Roman Catholic), Armenian Orthodox, Armenian Catholic, Maronite, Syrian Orthodox, Syrian Catholic, Chaldaic (Catholic) and Evangelical Episcopal (Anglican).
Judaism is a general requirement to be a member of the IDF, although there are a few Muslims and Christians serving in the Israeli military, in selective roles.
blowtorch_bob // Mar 1, 2010 at 12:45 pm
sinz54 :”…Israel, unlike the U.S., has an official religion (Judaism).”
The U.S. has an official religion too. It’s called free market ideology. The central tenant of this faith is that humankind is slowly evolving to some sort of Utopian enlightenment by the free markets. If the Vatican is the spiritual home of Roman Catholicism, then Wall Street is hallowed ground for free market ideology. Sure, there will be a bumps along the way like war, famine and misery and you may die in a gutter in the streets but it’s all for the best, you’ll see.